VIKTOR SHKLOVSKY IN THE MOSCOW LINGUISTIC CIRCLE
The article, “‘А History of the Novel / Romance’: Viktor Shklovsky in the Moscow Linguistic
Circle,” reconstructs the circumstances of Shklovsky’s first talk in the Moscow Linguistic
Circle (MLC) and outlines the history of his relationship with Moscow-based Formalists (1919–
1921). The authors describe the evolution of Shklovsky\’s theoretical views and determine that the
dominant theme of his work during this period was the theory of literary plot, in which the plot is
interpreted as an artistic device.
Shklovsky’s involvement in the activities of the MLC had a dual purpose: establishing relations
with the Petrograd community of literary scholars, who published, in May 1919, a collection of articles under the title: Poetics: Collections on the Theory of Poetic Language, as well as organizing
collaborative publishing projects. These intentions were never realized: after the Roman
Jakobson’s departure abroad, the MLC changed its methodological orientation and found itself in
crisis, which led to its disintegration. However, the aforementioned plan of collaboration between
the Moscow and Petrograd scholars served as a decisive stimulus for the design and of the
OPOIAZ (The Society for the Study of Poetic Language) in the Fall of 1919.
Shklovsky\’s scholarly interests at that time were focused on the study and systematic description
of the devices of plot-formation and the construction of a general theory of plot. From preliminary
generalizations on the art of cinema, he proceeded to the study of European classical
prose (Miguel Cervantes and Lawrence Stern). His talks given at the MLC in 1920 and 1921 were
devoted to the analysis of a literary plot in Don Quixote, Tristram Shandy, and the writings
of Vasilii Rozanov. These talks echoed his publications in The Life of Art. (The story of
Shklovsky’s short-term cooperation with this newspaper is also reconstructed in this article.)
The construction of the theory of plot soon became one of the Leitmotifs and, at the same
time, one of the constructive principles of organization of his own memoirist prose of the 1920s.
Shklovsky’s first talk at the MLC, the text of which did not survive, was delivered on June 10,
1919. It was titled “The History of the Novel” and caused a heated discussion about the literary
plot. The minutes from the meeting reveal that the speaker’s main opponent was Roman Jacobson,
a long-term friend and rival of Shklovsky.
The last section of this article includes a commented publication of the minutes from the
meeting of the MLC on June 10, 1919 and Jakobson’s notes made during the dispute that followed
Shklovsky’s début. (Both documents are preserved at the V.V. Vinogradov Russian Language
Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences in Moscow.)
[Bez podpisi (Shklovsky V.)] Izuchenie teorii poeticheskogo iazyka. Zhizn’ Iskusstva [The Life of Art], 1919, no. 273, 21 October, p. 2. (in Russ.)
Chudakova M. O., Toddes E. A. Stranitsy nauchnoi biografii B. M. Eikhenbauma. Voprosy literatury [The Issues of Literature], 1987, no. 1, p. 128–162. (in Russ.)
Eikhenbaum B. M. 5 = 100. Knizhnyi Ugol [A Book Corner], 1922, no. 8, p. 38‒41. (in Russ.)
Evreinov N., Eikhenbaum B., Belenson A. Prigovor suda chesti po delu ob obvinenii E. M. Kuznetsovym V. B. Shklovskogo v oskorblenii. In: Zhizn’ Iskusstva [The Life of Art], 1921, 16, 17, 19 apr., no. 718‒719‒720, p. 3. (in Russ.)
Jakobson R. An Example of Migratory Terms and Institutional Models (On the Fiftieth Anniversary of the Moscow Linguistic Circle). In: Jakobson R. Selected Writings. The Hague, Paris, Mouton Publishers, 1971, vol. 2: Word and Language, p. 527–538.
Jakobson R. O khudozhestvennom realizme. In: Jakobson R. Selected Writings. Ed., with a preface, by Stephen Rudy. The Hague, Paris, New York, Mouton Publishers, 1981, vol. 3: Poetry of Grammar and Grammar of Poetry, p. 723–731. (in Russ.)
Jakobson R. O. Moskovskii Lingvisticheskii Kruzhok. Philologica, 1996, vol. 3, no. 5/7, p. 361–380. (in Russ.)
Kirpichnikov A. I. Grecheskie romany v novoi literature. Povest’ o Varlaame i Ioasafe [Greek Novels in Modern Literature. The Tale of Varlaam and Ioasaph]. Kharkov, Izdatel’stvo Imperatorskogo Kharkovskogo universiteta, 1876, 268 p. (in Russ.)
Krusanov A. V. Russkii avangard, 1907‒1932 (Istoricheskii obzor) [The Russian Avant-guarde, 1907–1932 (Historical Overview)]. In 3 vols. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2003, vol. 2: The Futurist Revolution (1917–1921), 808 p. (in Russ.)
Lavrov A. V. B. M. Eikhenbaum v literaturnoi gazete «Irida». Vademecum: K 65-letiiu Lazaria Fleishmana [Vademecum: In Honor of Lazar Fleishman]. Comp. and ed. by A. Ustinov. Moscow, Vodolei, 2010, p. 201–213. (in Russ.)
Moskovskaia literaturnaia i filologicheskaia zhizn’ 1920-kh godov: mashinopisnyi zhurnal «Germes». I. Memuarnye zametki B. V. Gornunga. II. Ukazatel’ soderzhaniia zhurnala «Germes». III. K istorii mashinopisnykh izdanii 1920-kh godov, publ. M. O. Chudakovoi, G. A. Levintona, A. B. Ustinova. In: V Tynianovskie cheniya: Tezisy dokladov i materialy dlia obsuzhdeniia [Tynianov Readings 5: Presentations and Discussion Papers]. Ed. by E. A. Toddes. Riga, Zinatne, 1990, p. 167‒210. (in Russ.)
Nekrasov N. A. Polnoe sobranie sochinenii i pisem [Complete Works and Letters]. In 15 vols. Leningrad, Nauka, Leningradskoe otdelenie, 1981, vol. 2: Poems. 1855–1866, 448 p. (in Russ.)
Rozanov V. V. Neskol’ko slov o Gogole. Moskovskie Vedomosti [Moscow News], 1891, no. 46, 15 February, p. 3–4. (in Russ.)
Shapir M. I. M. M. Kenigsberg i ego fenomenologiia stikha. Russian Linguistics, 1994, vol. 18, no. 1, p. 73‒113. (in Russ.)
Sheldon R. Viktor Shklovsky: An International Bibliography of Works by and about Him. Ann Arbor, Ardis, 1977, 130 p.
Shklovsky V. «Eshche nichego ne konchilos’...» [“Nothing is Over Yet... ”]. Intr. A. Yu. Galushkin; comment. A. Yu. Galushkin, V. V. Nekhotin. Moscow, Propaganda, 2002, 461 p. (in Russ.)
Shklovsky V. Kinematograf kak iskusstvo. Zhizn’ Iskusstva [The Life of Art], 1919, no. 139‒140, 17‒18 May, p. 2; no. 141, 20 May, p. 2; no. 142, 21 May, p. 1–2. (in Russ.)
Shklovsky V. Literatura i kinematograf [Literature and Cinema]. Ber-lin, Russkaia universal’naia biblioteka, 1923, 59 p. (Vseobshchee znanie. No. 51) (in Russ.)
Shklovsky V. Razvertyvanie siuzheta (Roman-drama). Zhizn’ Iskusstva [The Life of Art], 1920, no. 348, 21 January, p. 1. (in Russ.)
Shklovsky V. Razvertyvanie siuzheta [The Unravelling of the Plot]. Petrograd, Izdatel’stvo «Opoyaz», 1921, 60 p. (in Russ.)
Shklovsky V. Razvertyvanie siuzheta. II. Zhizn’ Iskusstva [The Life of Art], 1920, no. 355, 27 January, p. 1. (in Russ.)
Shklovsky V. Rozanov. Iz knigi «Siuzhet kak iavlenie stilia» [Rozanov. From a Book entitled “The Plot as a Phenomenon of Style”]. [Petrograd], Izdatel’stvo «Opoyaz», 1921, 56 p. (in Russ.)
Shklovsky V. Sviaz’ priemov siuzhetoslozheniya s obshchimi priemami stilia. Poetika: Sborniki po teorii poeticheskogo iazyka. [Vyp. 1] [Poetics: On the Theory of Poetic Language. Vol. 1]. Petrograd, 18-ia Gosudarstvennaya tipografiia, 1919, p. 115–150. (in Russ.)
Shklovsky V. Siuzhet v stikhakh. Poieticheskii sbornik [Poetry Col-lection]. Moscow, Sovetskaya literatura, 1934, p. 173–194. (in Russ.)
Shklovsky V. Tekhnika romana tain. Lef, 1923, no. 4, p. 125–155. (in Russ.)
Shklovsky V. Tema, obraz i syuzhet Rozanova. Zhizn’ Iskusstva [The Life of Art], 1921, no. 697‒699, 19, 20, 22 March, p. 1–2; no. 712‒714, 6‒8 April, p. 2–3; no. 715‒717, 9, 10, 12 April, p. 1. (in Russ.)
Shklovsky V. Zhili-byli: Vospominaniia, memuarnye zapisi, povesti o vremeni: s kontsa XIX v. po 1962 g. [Once Upon a Time: Memoirs, Notes, Novellas about Time: from the End of the 19th Century to 1962] Moscow, Sovetskiy pisatel’, 1964, 482 p. (in Russ.)
Sorokina M. Yu. Emigrant No. 1017: Roman Jakobson v moskovskikh arkhivakh. Ezhegodnik Doma russkogo zarubezh’ia im. A. Solzhenitsyna [Yearbook of the Solzhenitsyn House of the Russians Abroad]. Moscow, 2016, p. 86–91. (in Russ.)
Stayner P. «Which side are you on, boy?» Roman Jakobson v Prage mezhvoennogo perioda. Slovo.ru: baltiiskii aktsent [Slovo.ru: Baltic Ac-cent], 2018, vol. 9, no. 1, p. 13–28. (in Russ.)
Siuzhet v kinematografe: Po materialam Moskovskogo lingvisticheskogo kruzhka, podg. teksta i komment. G. S. Barankovoi. Literaturnoe obozrenie [The Literary Review], 1997, no. 3, p. 81–84. (in Russ.)
Tikhonravov N. S. Russkie interliudii pervoi poloviny XVIII veka. Letopisi russkoi literatury i drevnosti [Chronicles of Russian Literature and Antiquity]. Moscow, Tipografiia Gracheva i K̊, 1859, vol. 2, pt. 2, p. 35–60. (in Russ.)
Tomashevsky i Moskovskii lingvisticheskii kruzhok, . Trudy po znakovym sistemam. IX [Sign Systems Studies. IX]. Tartu, Izdatel’stvo Tartuskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, 1977, p. 131‒132. (Uchenye zapiski Tartuskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Vyp. 422) (in Russ.)
Veselovsky A. N. Iz vvedeniia v istoricheskuiu poetiku. Zhurnal Ministerstva narodnogo prosveshcheniia [Journal of the Ministry of Popular Education], 1894, May. Otdel nauk, p. 21–42. (in Russ.)
Vinokur G. O. Moskovskii Lingvisticheskii Kruzhok. Akademicheskii tsentr Narkomprosa. Nauchnye izvestiia [Academic Center of the Narkompros. Academic News]. Moscow, Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo, 1922, vol. 2: Philosophy. Literature. Art, p. 289–290. (in Russ.)
VIKTOR SHKLOVSKY IN THE MOSCOW LINGUISTIC CIRCLE // Сюжетология и сюжетография. 2018. № 1. Pp. 5–23. DOI: 10.25205/2410-7883-2018-1-5-23.